Discussion:
[tor-relays] relay maintenance without losing consensus weight?
Zwiebel
2016-03-08 14:37:19 UTC
Permalink
Hello,
is there a way to shut down Tor relays for a short time without losing
consensus weight or bandwidth?

Last week I installed a newer Tor version and added more RAM and now my
relays lost a third of their bandwidth. Last time I've upgraded the
hardware was in January and the relays didn't fully recover from the downtime
in the last two months. I'd gladly provide 200Mb/s+ of relay bandwidth if I
could, but Tor won't let me.

- Zwiebel
Tim Wilson-Brown - teor
2016-03-08 15:20:09 UTC
Permalink
Post by Zwiebel
Hello,
is there a way to shut down Tor relays for a short time without losing
consensus weight or bandwidth?
This is a frequently asked question, particularly if you add "losing flags" to the relay operator's list of concerns.

I wonder if it's worth adding a FAQ or wiki entry with potential answers:

It takes time:
* wait, and the authorities and bandwidth authorities will re-assess your relay over about a week;
* clients may have given up on you as a guard, and may not come back for several months;

The network is dynamic:
* if the network is growing, your relay's share is going to be lower over time;
* if the network is not using its full relay capacity, this is good, because packets travel faster;
* (it's also good because sudden increases can be absorbed without impacting existing users);

We make bug fixes and add features:
* we recently fixed a bug where a relay would submit a descriptor with an 0 DirPort when it restarted (0.2.7.7 [unreleased], 0.2.8.1-alpha);
* in 0.2.8, network load is moved from the authorities to fallback directory mirrors, please opt-in if your relay is stable;
* in 0.2.8, network load is moved from directory mirrors with DirPorts, to almost all relays via tunnelled directory connections.
Depending on your relay's role in the network, it might see more or less traffic with these changes.
Post by Zwiebel
Last week I installed a newer Tor version and added more RAM and now my
relays lost a third of their bandwidth. Last time I've upgraded the
hardware was in January and the relays didn't fully recover from the downtime
in the last two months. I'd gladly provide 200Mb/s+ of relay bandwidth if I
could, but Tor won't let me.
Networks need extra capacity - it increases average speeds, and absorbs sudden usage spikes.
Consider starting a second tor instance on other ports to use the extra capacity on your server.

Tim

Tim Wilson-Brown (teor)

teor2345 at gmail dot com
PGP 968F094B

teor at blah dot im
OTR CAD08081 9755866D 89E2A06F E3558B7F B5A9D14F
Zwiebel
2016-03-08 18:18:51 UTC
Permalink
Post by Tim Wilson-Brown - teor
Post by Zwiebel
Hello,
is there a way to shut down Tor relays for a short time without losing
consensus weight or bandwidth?
This is a frequently asked question, particularly if you add "losing flags" to the relay operator's list of concerns.
So... is it possible?
Michael McConville
2016-03-08 18:26:19 UTC
Permalink
Post by Zwiebel
Post by Tim Wilson-Brown - teor
Post by Zwiebel
is there a way to shut down Tor relays for a short time without
losing consensus weight or bandwidth?
This is a frequently asked question, particularly if you add "losing
flags" to the relay operator's list of concerns.
So... is it possible?
I don't think that short maintenance outages should significantly impact
consensus weight. Bandwidth takes a little while to ramp back up because
people need to build circuits through your relay again.

Anyway, if you need to do maintenance, don't wait. The network benefits
more from a secure, reliable relay with 5% less consensus weight. :-)
Volker Mink
2016-03-08 18:30:39 UTC
Permalink
You can take it down for some days without losing any flags or consensus weight.
Had it with my exit i have at home.
I had to reinstall it and i have the same stats as before.

Best regards,
Volker
Post by Michael McConville
Post by Zwiebel
Post by Tim Wilson-Brown - teor
Post by Zwiebel
is there a way to shut down Tor relays for a short time without
losing consensus weight or bandwidth?
This is a frequently asked question, particularly if you add "losing
flags" to the relay operator's list of concerns.
So... is it possible?
I don't think that short maintenance outages should significantly impact
consensus weight. Bandwidth takes a little while to ramp back up because
people need to build circuits through your relay again.
Anyway, if you need to do maintenance, don't wait. The network benefits
more from a secure, reliable relay with 5% less consensus weight. :-)
_______________________________________________
tor-relays mailing list
https://lists.torproject.org/cgi-bin/mailman/listinfo/tor-relays
Random Tor Node Operator
2016-03-08 19:54:13 UTC
Permalink
Post by Volker Mink
You can take it down for some days without losing any flags or consensus weight.
Had it with my exit i have at home.
I had to reinstall it and i have the same stats as before.
The HSDir flag will be cleared after each restart of the Tor daemon, and
be set again after a certain amount of uptime.

The consensus weight doesn't change significantly due to short
maintenance outages.
Tim Wilson-Brown - teor
2016-03-09 01:16:13 UTC
Permalink
Post by Michael McConville
Post by Zwiebel
Post by Tim Wilson-Brown - teor
Post by Zwiebel
is there a way to shut down Tor relays for a short time without
losing consensus weight or bandwidth?
This is a frequently asked question, particularly if you add "losing
flags" to the relay operator's list of concerns.
So... is it possible?
I don't think that short maintenance outages should significantly impact
consensus weight. Bandwidth takes a little while to ramp back up because
people need to build circuits through your relay again.
Anyway, if you need to do maintenance, don't wait. The network benefits
more from a secure, reliable relay with 5% less consensus weight. :-)
If you take down your relay and keep the same key, IP address(es) and port(s), then most flags should come back quickly.
If you change any of those details, particularly the key, then the network will take some time (a week to several months) to re-evaluate your relay.

Tim

Tim Wilson-Brown (teor)

teor2345 at gmail dot com
PGP 968F094B

teor at blah dot im
OTR CAD08081 9755866D 89E2A06F E3558B7F B5A9D14F

Continue reading on narkive:
Search results for '[tor-relays] relay maintenance without losing consensus weight?' (Questions and Answers)
18
replies
i want to know about bermuda triangle?
started 2006-10-13 00:30:42 UTC
geography
Loading...